Modern Times Legal Patent Blog

New post at Inovia Blog re patenting in Africa

Posted on Thu, Jan 19, 2012 @ 03:30 PM

Per a request from Inovia, I recently wrote a guest for their Foreign Filing Blog, entitled, "Inside Perspective on Patenting at the African Regional Intellectual Property Office", where I shared some insights that I thought readers would find interesting and useful.

Expect more reports from visits to developing-world patent offices soon. Meanwhile, best wishes for a happy and prosperous 2012.

Tags: patent prosecution strategy, Africa, international

Slideshow: 'Understanding And Obtaining Patents And Managing Costs'

Posted on Fri, Mar 26, 2010 @ 09:30 PM

Below are the slides from a presentation on patents that I made to a joint meeting of the New England Sections of the American Ceramic Society and the International Microelectronics and Packaging Society in Marlborough, Massachusetts on March 24, 2010.

The slides are not entirely self-explanatory, so please feel free to contact me if you wish to further discuss any of these topics. 

Tags: patent prosecution strategy, international

Return visit to African Regional Intellectual Property Office (ARIPO)

Posted on Wed, Oct 21, 2009 @ 08:26 PM

African logoSorry that this blog has remained quiet for the past couple weeks--I have been in Africa.

Most American (or European, Japanese, Chinese, etc.) patent attorneys have never filed in Africa, though they should keep an eye on the continent, as patent filings are increasing at the African Regional Intellectual Property Office (ARIPO), even through the recession, while filings in America and in other developed markets have dropped.

Harare, Zimbabwe

Without many patent agents in ARIPO member states (e.g., there are just four patent agents in Zimbabwe), a critical need exists for patent drafters who can help to monetize innovation from African research centers, universities and other institutions. This past year, about 500 patent applications were filed at ARIPO (one of two regional patent organizaions along with French-speaking OAPI), though the overwhelming majority of those applications were filed by applicants from non-member countries, particularly from the United States and particularly directed to, for example, pharmaceuticals.

world logo

In the annual joint effort of the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) and ARIPO to build patent-drafting capacity in Africa, I again participated this past week as a patent-drafting instructor. After traveling to Addis Ababa, Ethiopia last year, this year we returned to the ARIPO headquarters in Harare, Zimbabwe with a new group of participants, this time from the following countries: Burundi, Ghana, Liberia, Mauritius, Namibia, Rwanda, Sierra Leone, Seychelles, Swaziland, and Zimbabwe. The program included a series of presentations discussing patents and patent-drafting concepts, as well as a series of practical patent claim-drafting exercises. Again, the students were highly committed and made remarkable progress in picking up concepts and skillfully employing claim drafting techniques in just one week.

ARIPO officials

Again, it was refreshing to meet high-ranking government officials, including the chairwoman of the council of ministers from Lesotho, who fully recognize that a strong intellectual property system is critical to investment and that skilled patent drafting is a critical need in that regard. African leaders recognize that a strong patent system is often needed to introduce new products to a country both from within as well as from outside the country's borders, as many companies will be afraid to enter a market if their innovations cannot be protected. I say "refreshing" because so many anti-patent interest groups in America today have forgotten or refuse to acknowledge this truth.

Bob Sayre at ARIPO

Patenting at ARIPO can cover 15 member states across Africa, and rules and procedures are governed by the Harare Protocol. As with European patents, ARIPO patents must be validated after issuance in the member states in which protection is sought. Patent rules in Africa mostly resemble European practice (e.g., using the problem-solution approach to evaluate the "inventive step" requirement), though ARIPO also employs some American concepts, such as the "best mode" requirement and the use of a "grace period" for filing after some disclosures (though ARIPO offers only a six-month grace period, rather than the one-year grace period foundin the US, and only for disclosures at officially recognized exhibitions).

Bob Sayre with lion cub

The Zimbabwean economy has stabilized--petrol stations have reopened, putting cars back on the road (not necessarily a good thing in my view); and supermarket shelves are once again stocked. Introduction of the US dollar as the official currency earlier this year, after Zim $100,000,000,000,000 (hundred trillion) notes were retired, appears to be the best thing to happen to the Zimbabwean economy in years.

Nevertheless, Morgan Tsvangarai and the MDC announced a boycott of the Zimbabwean "unity government" in combination with Robert Mugabe's Zanu PF party (Zanu PF headquarters shown at center in view of city from our hotel, above) due to the criminal prosecution of their appointed cabinet minister of agriculture over the weekend that we were there, which raised questions as to how long the unity government will hold, though there was no immediate apparent impact on safety or city functions.


Video of Bob introducing claim-drafting exercise:



Tags: Africa, international

Innovation everywhere - Africa and the developing world

Posted on Thu, Aug 13, 2009 @ 10:32 PM

Great Zimbabwe

WIPO/ARIPO instructors (Bob at left) and students from across Africa at Great Zimbabwe, near Masvingo, Zimbabwe (September 8, 2007).

"Zimbabwe" means stone house in the language of the Shona people. "Great Zimbabwe" now refers to the ruins of a great civilzation a couple hours from Harare with extraordinary dry stone constructions (i.e., formed of carved stone blocks and constructed without mortar). The earliest of these structures were believed to have been built around the year 1100, and the site is now a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

As colonial Rhodesia, the government would not accept that these remarkable structures were built by Africans, though it now appears clear that they were, in fact, built by remarkably innovative and sophisticated craftsmen who were ancient natives of what is now the country of Zimbabwe. Even today, these structures are a marvel of engineering; and needless to say, they were remarkably innovative 900 years ago.

Great Zimbabwe - conical tower

I was reminded of these impressions while recently reading Investment Biker by Jim Rogers. At one point, he reflected on a recognition that people from every society across the globe have achieved (and hold the potential for) highly advanced civilizations.

What struck me was the universal genius of man. I was reared to think that the glories of the Hebrews, the Greeks, and the Romans were the heights of ancient man's accomplishments. But this trip was opening my eyes. In Carthage, in Zimbabwe, in Xi'an, in the Sahara, and in Siberia--here in Tiahuanaco, Lake Titicaca, Suzdal, Istanbul, and Samarkand--I found ancient glory after ancient glory.

Id. at 340. I focus here on Great Zimbabwe simply because it is the only site among these that I have visited. Great Zimbabwe certainly does not fit the stereotype of "primitive" early Africans; and it made a strong impression on me as well--truly, we are all capable of greatness in every corner of the globe.

As we now enter a "flat world," opportunity for innovative contribution further opens up to all. My trip to Zimbabwe was on behalf of the World Intellectual Property Organization and the African Regional Intellectual Property Office to train Africans to draft patent applications. Recognizing that researchers at laboratories, universitites and other institutions across Africa continue to innovate and invent, a bottleneck to bringing these innovations to world markets in many developing regions is a scarcity of patent professionals to secure protection for these innovations; and our objective was to help build that capacity.

In short, opportunities now exist for unleashing this potential, and patents can play a key role in exporting innovations from developing regions and bringing them to market. Now more than ever, we have an opportunity to capitalize on innovation everywhere.


At the Scientific and Industrial Research and Development Centre in Harare, a biologist, above, explains his work in developing a drought-resistant variety of maize (corn). He and his colleagues are unphased by the dark during this power outage. Absent a reliable electrical grid, one of the most critical pieces of equipment in the lab is an uninterruptable power supply, so his innovative work determinatively carries on no matter the adversity.

For more examples of current innovation taking place in Africa, I highly recommend the recently launched blog from EGG-Energy from on the ground in Tanzania where they are working to more efficiently deliver electric power to the masses.

And if you are looking to secure global patent protection, I invite you to give me a call and I wil be happy to share more thoughts and explore whether I can help.

Tags: inventors, Africa, international

When amending claims in PCT applications, all claim pages must now be replaced

Posted on Tue, Jul 07, 2009 @ 11:09 AM

Hat tip to Peter Zura at the 271 blog for the practice-tip reminder that you must now replace all claims when making amendments in PCT applications (not just the pages on which amendments are made). Peter points to the USPTO Notice on his blog, though take note that the USPTO is merely implementing a change in the PCT Rules (specifically Rule 66.8), effective July 1.

Accordingly, practitioners should recognize that this is a PCT Rule (not just US), so likewise take note if you selected another office (such as the European Patent Office, the Korean IP Office, or IP Australia) for search and examination to prevent your claim amendments from being bounced.

Tags: international, rules

Business Week Ranks Boston #3 Among World's Most Inventive Cities

Posted on Sun, May 10, 2009 @ 09:04 AM

Business Week, to my eye, is often misguided in its patent reporting; and there is plenty of reason to be suspicious of any ranking system suggesting any kind of precisions.Nevertheless, I believe the following characterization accurately pinned down Greater Boston:

"Boston's prowess in intellectual property stems from its world-renowned research centers, Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Harvard University."

The extent to which the local technology landscape is rooted in the work of our local universities, is truly impressive both in terms of the technology, itself, and in terms of the remarkably talented people they have attracted.

In Business Week's report on inventive cities, San Francisco / Silicon Valley topped the rankings and Tokyo was #2. Boston was the only city on the east coast to crack the top ten.And, of course, their references to "Boston" mean (or should mean) Cambridge at least as much as Boston.

Also reported in this issue, for the first time, foreign applicants secured more US patents than did American applicants last year "due mostly to an upsurge in patents to inventors in Japan, South Korea, and China":

Hat tip to Patent Hawk for spotting these articles first (

Tags: international, Boston/Cambridge

Interesting 2008 PCT Statistics

Posted on Wed, Apr 15, 2009 @ 02:53 PM

The World Intellectual Property Organization has now issued its PCT Yearly Review for 2008. For the uninitiated,the Patent Cooperation Treaty affords an international patent filing procedure providing a single preliminary examination before an applicant needs to branch into national stage filings in the countries and regions of interest.

The chart that I found most interesting was the listing of the top 15 countries of origin (measured by the country of the first named applicant),see below (if the chart is clipped,you can click it to see it in its entirety).Not surprisingly, fast-growing Korea (+12.0%) and China(+11.9%) both increased their filings by double digits (percentage-wise) over 2007.Though I was a bit surprised to learn that the other top-15 country to achieve double-digit growth was Sweden (+12.5%).Filings from the United States, in contrast, dropped by 1.0%.

Also interesting was that Huawei Technologies Co. of China catapulted its way past Philips and Panasonic into the top spot for PCT filings with 1,737 PCT applications filed in 2008 (yep, that's almost 5 new filings for every day of the year).

Finally, the fastest-growing technical fields (by number of PCT applications) were IT methods for management (+22.7% annual growth) and micro-structural and nanotechnology (+20.7% annual growth).

Tags: international